
The Beekman
Best for dramatic historic architecture, Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud restaurants, and a Financial District base close to Lower Manhattan landmarks.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a 287-room, landmarked five-star hotel in Lower Manhattan centered on a nine-story Victorian atrium and destination dining; this guide is for travelers who want historic architecture, downtown dining, and an adult-leaning boutique stay. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a globally recognized five-star luxury hotel on E 57th Street; this comparison is for travelers who prioritize traditional, centrally located Midtown luxury and internationally known service.
Updated · about 5.5 km apart

Best for dramatic historic architecture, Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud restaurants, and a Financial District base close to Lower Manhattan landmarks.

Best for classic Midtown five-star luxury, easy access to Central Park/5th Avenue attractions, and a full-scale luxury hotel program.
When The Beekman wins: choose The Beekman if you want landmark architecture and an intimate downtown address with multiple high-profile chef-driven restaurants and a distinctly historic setting.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: pick the Four Seasons if you want an established global five-star name in Midtown near Central Park and 5th Avenue, and prefer a traditional full-service luxury hotel program.
Bottom line: both are high-end Manhattan stays; The Beekman leans historic and downtown dining, while Four Seasons Hotel New York is the safer pick for classic Midtown luxury and international-brand expectations.
| Category | The Beekman | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, dramatic atrium; boutique five-star in the Financial District | Classic, established five-star luxury in Midtown Manhattan |
| Location | 123 Nassau Street — Financial District, steps from City Hall Park, Brooklyn Bridge, and 9/11 Memorial area | 57 E 57th Street — Midtown, near 5th Avenue and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 287 rooms (including 38 suites, plus two turret penthouses) | 368 rooms |
| Ages / policy | Adult-leaning boutique; must be 21 to reserve; children welcome with registered adult | All ages welcome; not adults-only (minimum age to book: 18 at check-in per supplier listing) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues (Temple Court by Tom Colicchio, The Bar Room, Le Gratin by Daniel Boulud) plus a cocktail lounge | One main restaurant (The Garden Restaurant) and a bar/lounge; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; in-room spa treatments arranged by concierge; 24-hour bi-level fitness center with Peloton bikes | Not published |
| Known for | Restored 1881 Temple Court building and nine-story atrium; chef-driven downtown dining | Globally recognized five-star service and proximity to Central Park and 5th Avenue |
| Event & wedding spaces | Multiple historic event rooms including The Cellar (3,100 sq ft) and rooftop buyout options; wedding capacity up to ~90 guests | Conference center and ~12,120 sq ft of meeting space (conference/ballroom facilities) |
| Accessibility & family services | Babysitting/childcare available (surcharge); pet policy allows dogs up to 35 lbs (fee); wheelchair accessible public areas | Supervised childcare/activities (surcharge); wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); pet arrangements by contacting property |
The Beekman sits in Lower Manhattan’s Financial District with immediate access to downtown landmarks.
Choose The Beekman for a downtown base and short walks to Financial District and southern Manhattan attractions.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is on E 57th Street, putting Midtown attractions within easy reach.
Pick Four Seasons for classic Midtown access and proximity to Central Park and major museums.
The Beekman’s guestrooms and suites are housed in a restored 19th-century building with signature turret penthouses.
The Beekman is the choice if you want rooms that highlight the building’s historic character and unique penthouse terraces.
Four Seasons Hotel New York offers a large room inventory with a range of junior and multi-bedroom suites.
Choose Four Seasons for a broad selection of traditionally appointed luxury rooms and large suites.
Dining at The Beekman centers on chef-driven venues from well-known New York chefs.
The Beekman is the pick for food-focused travelers who want multiple high-profile chef restaurants inside the hotel.
Four Seasons Hotel New York offers a single main restaurant plus bar/lounge and 24-hour room service.
Choose Four Seasons if you prefer a traditional hotel restaurant and full room service typical of five-star Midtown hotels.
The Beekman’s defining feature is its nine-story Victorian atrium and landmark architecture.
The Beekman’s architecture is the hotel’s signature—best valued by guests who care about historic settings.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is known as a full-scale, globally recognized five-star property.
Pick Four Seasons for a broadly resourced, full-service luxury experience in Midtown.
The Beekman supports wellness with a 24-hour fitness center and arranged in-room spa services.
The Beekman is good for fitness-minded guests and those who prefer in-room treatments to a dedicated spa.
Four Seasons lists fitness and concierge services as part of its amenities.
Four Seasons provides traditional luxury hotel services and 24-hour fitness access; spa/pool specifics are not published in the supplied listing.

The Beekman — choose it for the nine-story atrium, restored 1881 Temple Court setting, and turret penthouse terraces.

Four Seasons Hotel New York — choose it for proximity to 5th Avenue, Central Park, and Midtown cultural sites.

The Beekman — three on-site venues including Temple Court (Tom Colicchio) and Le Gratin (Daniel Boulud).

Four Seasons Hotel New York — a globally recognized five-star brand with a large room inventory and conference facilities.
The Beekman — it’s in the Financial District within easy walking distance of Wall Street, the Brooklyn Bridge, and Battery Park ferry departures.
Four Seasons Hotel New York — its E 57th Street address places you close to Central Park, 5th Avenue, and Midtown cultural attractions.
The Beekman does not have an on-site pool or spa and instead offers in-room spa treatments and a 24-hour fitness center. Four Seasons Hotel New York’s supplied listing does not publish pool or spa details.
Both welcome families: The Beekman is adult-leaning and requires a registered guest aged 21 to reserve; Four Seasons accepts all ages and lists supervised childcare/activities (surcharge).
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·