
The Beekman
Best for food-focused stays and a landmark building experience with Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a five-star, historic Lower Manhattan hotel centered on a restored 19th-century atrium with chef-led restaurants — best for travelers who want downtown history, dining, and a boutique, adult-leaning atmosphere. Royalton Park Avenue is a five-star Midtown/Flatiron luxury hotel on Park Avenue South with a rooftop restaurant and central Midtown access — best for guests who want a Park Avenue address and quick walks to Empire State/Flatiron attractions.
Updated · about 2.7 km apart

Best for food-focused stays and a landmark building experience with Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud venues.

Best for Midtown sightseeing, a Park Avenue address, and a rooftop dining option close to the Empire State Building.
When The Beekman wins: pick The Beekman if you want a landmark hotel with distinctive historic architecture, multiple chef-driven restaurants, penthouse terraces, and an adult-leaning boutique feel in the Financial District.
When Royalton Park Avenue wins: pick Royalton Park Avenue if you need a Midtown/Flatiron location for sightseeing, want a rooftop restaurant and outdoor pool access, and prefer a larger hotel footprint with 24-hour services and valet parking options.
Bottom line: both are five-star Manhattan hotels; choose The Beekman for character, signature dining, and downtown access, or choose Royalton Park Avenue for a central Park Avenue/Flatiron location with rooftop dining and an outdoor pool.
| Category | The Beekman | Royalton Park Avenue |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Beaux-Arts landmark boutique with Victorian atrium and historic details | Contemporary Midtown luxury on Park Avenue South with rooftop terrace |
| Location | Financial District — near City Hall Park, Brooklyn Bridge, 9/11 Memorial | Park Avenue South / Flatiron area — short walk to Empire State Building & Madison Square Park |
| Size | 287 rooms (including 38 suites, 2 turret penthouses) | 249 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum 21 to reserve a room | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Outdoor pool (number of outdoor pools: 1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Three venues (Temple Court by Tom Colicchio, The Bar Room, Le Gratin by Daniel Boulud) plus cocktail lounge | Royalton Rooftop (French-leaning) plus 24-hour room service; 1 restaurant listed |
| Spa / treatments | No on-site spa; concierge-arranged in-room spa treatments with guest discount | Body treatments and facials available; a health/beauty spa nearby is listed |
| Fitness | Bi-level, 24-hour fitness center with Peloton bikes | 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Parking & arrival | No on-site garage; nearby valet parking arranged (surcharge) | Valet parking available (surcharge); covered and secured parking listed |
| Notable features | Nine-story Victorian atrium, turret penthouses with private terraces, chef-led destination dining | Rooftop terrace/restaurant, close walking distance to Empire State Building and Madison Square Park |
The Beekman sits in Lower Manhattan’s Financial District, steps from City Hall Park, Wall Street, and the Brooklyn Bridge.
Choose The Beekman for historic downtown access and short walks to Lower Manhattan landmarks.
Royalton Park Avenue is centrally located on Park Avenue South, within easy walking distance of the Empire State Building and Madison Square Park.
Choose Royalton Park Avenue for Midtown sightseeing and a Park Avenue address.
The Beekman offers a range of 287 rooms, including 38 suites and two distinctive turret penthouses with private rooftop terraces.
Pick The Beekman for distinctive suite options and turret penthouse terraces.
Royalton Park Avenue has 249 guestrooms with standard luxury in-room conveniences.
Royalton is a solid Midtown choice with standard luxury room amenities and hotel services.
Dining is a major reason to stay at The Beekman — three venues run by high-profile chefs.
If restaurant programs and chef-driven menus matter, The Beekman leads.
Royalton Park Avenue highlights a rooftop restaurant and 24-hour room service.
Royalton is a good pick for rooftop dining and in-room service in Midtown.
The Beekman does not operate an on-site swimming pool or hot tub; its signature features are the atrium and rooftop penthouses.
Not for travelers who need an on-site pool; pick The Beekman for architecture and private terrace experiences.
Royalton Park Avenue lists an outdoor pool and rooftop terrace as on-property amenities.
Choose Royalton if an on-site outdoor pool and rooftop outdoor space are priorities.
The Beekman focuses on fitness access and in-room spa treatments rather than an on-site spa.
The Beekman suits travelers who want fitness facilities, in-room treatments, and an upscale cocktail scene.
Royalton Park Avenue provides 24-hour fitness facilities and lists spa/body treatments and a rooftop nightlife vibe.
Royalton fits guests looking for a fitness option plus an evening rooftop restaurant/terrace.

The Beekman — multiple chef-led venues including Tom Colicchio's Temple Court and Daniel Boulud's Le Gratin.

Royalton Park Avenue — short walks to the Empire State Building, Flatiron, and Madison Square Park.

The Beekman — landmark Temple Court Building with a nine-story Victorian atrium and turret penthouses.

Royalton Park Avenue — rooftop terrace and one outdoor pool listed among hotel amenities.
The Beekman — it's in the Financial District within walking distance of Wall Street, the Brooklyn Bridge, and the 9/11 Memorial.
Royalton Park Avenue lists an outdoor pool and spa/body treatments; The Beekman does not have an on-site pool or spa but arranges in-room treatments.
No. Both properties accept guests of all ages; The Beekman is adult-leaning and requires a 21+ registered guest to reserve a room.
The Beekman — three distinct on-site venues run by notable chefs provide a range of dinner, brunch, and bar options.
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·