
The Beekman
Best for travelers who want a dramatic, historic setting with multiple signature restaurants and lively evening venues in downtown Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a five-star Lower Manhattan landmark hotel built around a nine-story Victorian atrium and known for lively destination dining — read this if you want a downtown, characterful stay with active nightlife and event spaces. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is a relaunched five-star Upper East Side property near Central Park offering refined rooms and a full-service spa — read this if you prefer a quieter, museum-and-shopping–focused uptown base.
Updated · about 6 km apart

Best for travelers who want a dramatic, historic setting with multiple signature restaurants and lively evening venues in downtown Manhattan.

Best for travelers who want an Upper East Side location steps from museums and Central Park with a traditional luxury hotel experience and on-site spa.
When The Beekman wins: choose The Beekman if you want downtown energy, landmark architecture (the nine-story atrium), multiple chef-driven restaurants and late-night bar/lounge options, plus more event and wedding spaces.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: pick The Surrey for a quieter, uptown location close to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art, smaller scale (about 100 rooms), and a full-service spa for on‑site treatments.
Bottom line: Both are five-star New York hotels aimed at luxury travelers who value character; The Beekman leans theatrical and social in Lower Manhattan, while The Surrey is a refined, uptown alternative focused on neighborhood access and spa-based relaxation.
| Category | The Beekman | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, theatrical, downtown energy with active dining and nightlife | Quieter, uptown refinement with classic luxury service |
| Location | Financial District — close to City Hall Park, Brooklyn Bridge and 9/11 Memorial | Upper East Side — a 5-minute walk from Central Park and near the Met |
| Size (rooms) | 287 rooms, including 38 suites and two turret penthouse duplexes | 100 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; a registered guest must be 21+ to reserve | |
| Pools | No on-site pool or hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three signature dining venues (Temple Court, The Bar Room, Le Gratin) plus late-night Laissez Faire lounge | Casa Tua (Italian) plus 24-hour room service; one bar/lounge listed |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; concierge-arranged in-room treatments with a 10% guest discount; 24-hour bi-level fitness center with Peloton bikes | Full-service spa on property and 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Restored 1881 Temple Court Building with a dramatic nine-story atrium and chef-driven restaurants | Relaunched Corinthia-branded Upper East Side hotel steps from Central Park and the Met |
| Parking & transfers | No on-site garage; nearby valet parking available (starting around $95/day); house car service available | Covered valet parking available (surcharge) and limo/town car service listed |
| Pet policy | Dogs welcome up to 35 lbs for a nonrefundable fee (hotel FAQ lists $150 per stay) | Pet fee listed (USD 275 per pet, per stay) with service animals exempt |
The Beekman sits in Lower Manhattan’s Financial District, steps from City Hall Park and downtown landmarks.
Choose The Beekman if you want to be in the heart of downtown, near Wall Street and waterfront attractions.
The Surrey is on East 76th Street, a short walk from Central Park and major museums on the Upper East Side.
Choose The Surrey for easy access to Central Park and the city’s major museum corridor.
The Beekman is larger with many room types and distinctive turret penthouse suites.
The Beekman offers more variety and dramatic signature suites for milestone stays or larger groups.
The Surrey is smaller (about 100 guestrooms) and positions itself as an Upper East Side luxury hotel.
The Surrey feels more intimate in scale with classic luxury room amenities and several suite levels.
Dining at The Beekman is a focal point — multiple venues by high-profile chefs.
If restaurant variety and nightlife are important, The Beekman has the edge.
The Surrey lists Casa Tua as its on-site Italian restaurant plus 24-hour room service.
The Surrey suits travelers who want quality dining without the downtown scene; it’s quieter and more neighborhood-focused.
The Beekman does not have a pool; its facilities emphasize fitness, events and historic spaces.
The Beekman is better for guests who prioritize fitness and memorable event spaces over on-site pool time.
The Surrey highlights a full-service spa alongside standard luxury amenities.
The Surrey is the pick for travelers who want on-site spa treatments and a quieter, restorative stay.
The Beekman mixes wellness with active nightlife and late-night venues.
Combine workouts with lively evenings at The Beekman; it’s social and event-focused.
The Surrey prioritizes spa services and a calm uptown environment over nightlife.
Expect a low-key evening rhythm at The Surrey geared toward relaxation and museum/park outings.

The Beekman — multiple chef-driven restaurants, a lively bar room and a separate late-night lounge.

The Surrey — a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The Beekman — landmarked Temple Court Building with a dramatic nine-story atrium.

The Surrey — lists a full-service spa and treatment rooms on property.
The Surrey is closer to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; choose it if museums and park time are a priority.
The Beekman — it has three distinct restaurants, a lively bar, and a late-night lounge with evening programming.
The Beekman does not have an on-site pool; The Surrey’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Both accept guests of all ages, but The Beekman is adult-leaning in tone; both properties require a registered guest age (21+) to book the room.
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·