
The Beekman
Best for history, dramatic architecture, and destination restaurants by Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a five-star Lower Manhattan landmark hotel built around a dramatic nine-story Victorian atrium and aimed at travellers who want downtown history, destination dining, and an adult-leaning boutique feel. The St. Regis New York is a legendary Midtown five-star grand hotel for readers who value classic formal service, a central Midtown address near 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center, and traditional five-star amenities.
Updated · about 6 km apart

Best for history, dramatic architecture, and destination restaurants by Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud.

Best for a traditional Midtown luxury stay, formal service, and proximity to 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
When The Beekman wins: pick The Beekman if you want a distinctive historic building, a downtown location near the Brooklyn Bridge and One World Trade Center, and multiple chef-driven restaurants in-house.
When The St. Regis New York wins: choose The St. Regis for a classic Midtown address, a long-standing reputation for formal five-star service (including rooms with Butler Service listed), and extensive meeting/banquet facilities in central Manhattan.
Bottom line: both are landmark luxury hotels serving different parts of Manhattan—The Beekman is downtown, boutique and culinary-focused; The St. Regis is Midtown, formal and traditionally five-star. Your choice depends mostly on which neighborhood and style you prefer.
| Category | The Beekman | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown boutique with a dramatic atrium and culinary focus | Legendary Midtown grand hotel, formal five-star service |
| Location | 123 Nassau Street, Financial District — close to Brooklyn Bridge, One World Trade Center, 9/11 Memorial | Two East 55th St, Midtown — steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms) | 287 rooms including 38 suites and two penthouse turrets | 238 air-conditioned guestrooms (selection of suites and studio options) |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool or hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three: Temple Court (Tom Colicchio), The Bar Room, Le Gratin (Daniel Boulud) plus Laissez-Faire lounge | Two restaurants and 1 bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; concierge-arranged in-room treatments with a 10% guest discount; 24-hour bi-level fitness center with Peloton bikes | Not published |
| Known for | Restored 1881 Temple Court Building, nine-story atrium, chef-driven dining and turret penthouses | Classic St. Regis brand service, Butler Service room types, central Midtown address |
| Meetings & events | Several historic meeting rooms and event spaces including The Cellar (3,100 sq ft) and rooftop buyout; max capacities suited to medium-sized events | Conference space 3944 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms for larger Midtown events |
| Accessibility & family policy | All ages welcome; minimum 21 to reserve a room; babysitting available (surcharge) | Welcomes guests of all sexual orientations and gender identities; check-in min age 21 per supplier listing |
The Beekman sits in Lower Manhattan’s Financial District at 123 Nassau Street with walking access to Wall Street, the Brooklyn Bridge, and Battery Park ferry services.
Pick The Beekman for easy access to downtown sights and the waterfront.
The St. Regis New York is centrally located at Two East 55th St, a short walk from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Choose The St. Regis for a Midtown base near major museums, shopping and Midtown attractions.
The Beekman’s 287 rooms include 38 suites and two signature turret penthouses with private rooftop terraces.
The Beekman’s appeal is in its historic architecture and signature penthouse terraces.
The St. Regis lists 238 air-conditioned guestrooms, many offered with Butler Service included in the room type name.
St. Regis emphasizes traditional suite options and Butler Service for a formal luxury stay.
The Beekman centers its food-and-beverage offering on three on-site restaurants by high-profile chefs and a cocktail lounge.
Choose The Beekman if on-site, chef-driven dining is a priority.
The St. Regis New York offers two restaurants and a bar/lounge with room service during limited hours.
St. Regis is a solid choice for classic hotel dining and convenient Midtown meal options.
The Beekman’s signature is its restored 19th-century Temple Court Building atrium and rooftop turret penthouses.
The atrium and turret terraces are The Beekman’s defining features.
The St. Regis highlights traditional five-star service, including Butler Service offered with multiple room types, and substantial meeting facilities.
St. Regis stands out for formal service touches and extensive Midtown meeting space.
The Beekman provides a bi-level 24-hour fitness center and arranges in-room spa treatments through outside providers.
Good for guests who want 24-hour fitness and curated in-room spa services rather than a full spa facility.
The St. Regis includes a 24-hour fitness facility and at least one bar/lounge; supplier listing does not publish an on-site spa detail.
Expect formal hotel nightlife and 24-hour gym access; spa and pool details are not published in the supplier listing.

The Beekman — the restored Temple Court atrium and turret penthouses are central to its identity.

The St. Regis New York — steps from 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and Midtown shopping and museums.

The Beekman — three distinct restaurants including venues by Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud.

The St. Regis New York — Butler Service room types and 13 meeting rooms with nearly 3,944 sq ft of conference space.
The St. Regis New York — it’s on East 55th Street, steps from 5th Avenue and a short walk to Rockefeller Center and MoMA.
The Beekman — it has three on-site restaurants including Temple Court (Tom Colicchio) and Le Gratin (Daniel Boulud).
The Beekman does not have a pool and does not operate an on-site spa (it offers concierge-arranged in-room treatments). The St. Regis supplier listing does not publish pool or spa details.
Both welcome guests of all ages, but The Beekman is described as adult-leaning; The Beekman and The St. Regis list minimums or check-in-age policies (The Beekman requires a 21+ person to reserve). Babysitting services are available at The Beekman.
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·