
The Beekman
Best for guests who want a revived, social downtown hotel with signature restaurants and dramatic architecture.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a restored five-star landmark in Lower Manhattan with a dramatic nine-story atrium and downtown dining by Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud; this guide is for travelers who want a lively, design-forward hotel near the Brooklyn Bridge and FiDi. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side five-star institution with old‑New‑York cachet; read on if you prefer a classic, discreet luxury address close to Central Park and museum mile.
Updated

Best for guests who want a revived, social downtown hotel with signature restaurants and dramatic architecture.

Best for travelers seeking old‑New‑York refinement, proximity to Central Park and museum mile, and Rosewood service.
When The Beekman wins: Choose The Beekman if you want a character-rich, visually dramatic downtown stay with multiple destination restaurants (Temple Court, The Bar Room, Le Gratin), a 24‑hour fitness center, and easy access to FiDi sights like the Brooklyn Bridge and One World Trade Center.
When The Carlyle wins: Choose The Carlyle if you value a classic Upper East Side address steps from Central Park and the Met, prefer a quieter, residential luxury atmosphere, and want Rosewood’s traditional hotel service and on‑site full‑service spa.
Bottom line: Both are luxury hotels with strong personalities — pick The Beekman for high‑energy downtown dining and landmark architecture, or The Carlyle for old‑school Upper East Side polish and proximity to the museums and Central Park.
| Category | The Beekman | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored Victorian‑era atrium, lively downtown energy, social dining destinations | Stately Upper East Side institution with refined, reservation‑style service |
| Location | Financial District, near Brooklyn Bridge, City Hall Park, One World Trade Center | Upper East Side, within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size (rooms) | 287 rooms (including 38 suites and two turret penthouse suites) | 188 guestrooms |
| Age / character | Built 1881 (Temple Court Building), restored historic landmark | Storied, historic hotel with longstanding New York social cachet |
| Pools | No on‑site pool or hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on‑site venues: Temple Court (Tom Colicchio), The Bar Room, Le Gratin (Daniel Boulud); also Laissez Faire cocktail lounge | Two restaurants, Bemelman's Bar and a coffee shop/cafe; 24‑hour room service available |
| Spa / wellness | No on‑site spa; concierge‑arranged in‑room treatments and a bi‑level 24‑hour fitness center with Peloton bikes | Full‑service spa and health club on property |
| Known for | Dramatic nine‑story atrium, downtown dining by high‑profile chefs, turret penthouses with terraces | Bemelman's Bar, proximity to Central Park and major museums, Rosewood heritage |
| Accessibility & family policy | All ages welcome; minimum booking age 21; babysitting available (surcharge) | All ages welcome; not adults‑only |
| Included Wi‑Fi | Unlimited premium high‑speed Wi‑Fi included | |
The Beekman sits at 123 Nassau Street in Lower Manhattan’s Financial District, steps from City Hall Park and the Brooklyn Bridge.
Pick The Beekman for downtown sightseeing, historic neighborhoods, and access to FiDi transit hubs.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street on the Upper East Side, within a short walk of Central Park and museum mile.
Choose The Carlyle when you want classic Upper East Side quiet and immediate access to Central Park and the Met.
The Beekman has 287 rooms with a mix of standard rooms, 38 suites and two signature turret penthouses with private terraces.
The Beekman leans into landmark architecture and distinctive suites, including penthouses with private outdoor space.
The Carlyle offers 188 guestrooms including a long list of superior, deluxe, premier rooms and numerous suites.
The Carlyle presents classic, well‑equipped rooms and many named suites that reflect its heritage and service level.
The Beekman emphasizes dining as a reason to stay, with restaurants by Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud plus late‑night and cocktail venues.
If dining and lively hotel bars are central to your trip, The Beekman’s chef‑driven venues make it a strong pick.
The Carlyle’s food and beverage offerings are part of its classic identity, anchored by Bemelman's Bar and formal restaurant options.
Choose The Carlyle if you prefer classic hotel dining and an iconic bar experience near museum mile and Central Park.
The Beekman does not have a pool; its signature non‑guestroom amenities are the restored atrium, destination restaurants, and a bi‑level 24‑hour fitness center.
The Beekman’s main draw is its dramatic public spaces and round‑the‑clock fitness facilities rather than a pool or spa.
The Carlyle’s highlighted amenity in supplier materials is a full‑service spa and health club on property.
If a dedicated on‑site spa and a quieter wellness environment matter, The Carlyle is the better fit.
The Beekman supports active guests with its 24‑hour fitness center and offers lively evening options like The Bar Room’s jazz brunch and Laissez Faire late‑night lounge.
The Beekman blends fitness access with an active food and drink program—good for guests who want nightlife without leaving the hotel.
The Carlyle offers a more traditional evening experience anchored by Bemelman's Bar and formal dining, paired with on‑site spa facilities for daytime wellness.
The Carlyle suits travelers who prefer classic evening bars and an on‑site spa rather than a hotel nightlife scene.

The Beekman — chef‑driven restaurants by Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud, a lively Bar Room and a late‑night cocktail lounge.

The Carlyle — an Upper East Side address steps from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The Beekman — the restored nine‑story Victorian atrium with pyramidal skylight is the hotel’s centerpiece.

The Carlyle — supplier listing includes a full‑service spa and health club on property.
The Beekman is in the Financial District, within easy walking distance of the Brooklyn Bridge, One World Trade Center, the 9/11 Memorial & Museum and ferry departures.
The Carlyle is on the Upper East Side, a short walk from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The Beekman does not have a pool or on‑site full spa (in‑room treatments are available); the Carlyle’s supplier listing notes a full‑service spa and health club.
Both accept guests of all ages, but The Beekman requires the reserving guest to be at least 21; babysitting services are available at The Beekman for a surcharge.
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·