
The Beekman
Best for travelers who want restored Victorian architecture, downtown sights, and notable chef-driven restaurants.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a restored 19th-century landmark hotel in Lower Manhattan centered on a dramatic nine-story Victorian atrium; read this if you want historic character, downtown access, and chef-driven dining. The Peninsula New York is a Fifth Avenue, full-service luxury hotel in Midtown with a spa and indoor pool; read this if you want classic Fifth Avenue address and Midtown sightseeing convenience.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for travelers who want restored Victorian architecture, downtown sights, and notable chef-driven restaurants.

Best for travelers who prefer a classic Fifth Avenue address, an on-site spa and an indoor pool in Midtown.
When The Beekman wins: choose The Beekman if you prioritize landmark architecture, a dramatic central atrium, and downtown/Financial District access — plus dining from high-profile chefs and a compact, boutique feel.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you want a Midtown Fifth Avenue base for museums, shopping and theaters, and prefer an on-site full-service spa, indoor pool, and traditional palace-style hotel services.
Bottom line: both are five-star New York hotels with different personalities — The Beekman is about history and downtown character; The Peninsula New York is about Fifth Avenue luxury and comprehensive on-site wellness amenities.
| Category | The Beekman | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Victorian atrium, restored landmark, downtown boutique luxury | Beaux-Arts/Beaux Arts Fifth Avenue palace-style luxury |
| Location | Financial District / Lower Manhattan — close to City Hall Park, Brooklyn Bridge, 9/11 Memorial | Midtown Manhattan — on Fifth Avenue near MoMA, Rockefeller Center, shopping |
| Size (rooms) | 287 rooms including 38 suites and two turret penthouse duplexes | 219 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; reservation minimum age 21 to book | |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Indoor pool (one) |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues (Temple Court, The Bar Room, Le Gratin) with prominent chef names | Number of restaurants - 1; Number of bars/lounges - 3 (Clement Restaurant and three bars/lounges listed) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; concierge-arranged in-room spa treatments with a guest discount | Full-service spa with treatment rooms, plus sauna and 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Restored Temple Court Building, nine-story atrium, chef-driven dining and event spaces | Fifth Avenue location, palace-style luxury, full-service spa and indoor pool |
| Event & meeting spaces | Several historic event rooms including The Cellar (3,100 sq ft) and multiple meeting rooms | Five meeting rooms; banquet and meeting facilities listed |
| Transport & access | Near Fulton St subway connections and Battery Park ferry access; no on-site parking garage (nearby valet) | Steps from 5th Avenue and near subway/station options; secured parking and valet available (surcharge) |
The Beekman sits in the Financial District within the restored Temple Court Building at 123 Nassau Street.
Choose The Beekman for historic Lower Manhattan access and walking proximity to downtown landmarks.
The Peninsula New York is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street in Midtown Manhattan.
Choose The Peninsula for a central Midtown base near museums, shopping and theater districts.
The Beekman has 287 rooms, including 38 suites and two signature Turret Penthouse duplexes.
Choose The Beekman if you want rooms that reflect landmark architecture and signature penthouse terraces.
The Peninsula New York lists 219 guestrooms across classic Fifth Avenue accommodations.
Choose The Peninsula for a traditional luxury hotel room experience on Fifth Avenue.
The Beekman emphasizes dining with venues from high-profile chefs.
The Beekman is a strong pick for food-focused travelers seeking notable chef-driven restaurants in-house.
The Peninsula New York features Clement Restaurant plus multiple bars and 24-hour room service.
The Peninsula serves classic hotel dining and multiple lounge options for Midtown eating and drinking.
The Beekman does not operate an on-site swimming pool or hot tub.
If an on-site pool matters, The Beekman is not the right choice.
The Peninsula New York offers an indoor pool and pool-related amenities.
Choose The Peninsula for an on-site indoor pool and a more complete in-house wellness experience.
The Beekman focuses on fitness and in-room spa services rather than an on-site full spa.
The Beekman suits guests who want 24-hour fitness and curated in-room treatments with downtown evening options.
The Peninsula New York offers a full-service spa, sauna and 24-hour fitness facilities.
The Peninsula is the better choice for travelers who prioritize an on-site spa and round-the-clock fitness plus in-hotel nightlife.

The Beekman — landmark Temple Court building with a nine-story Victorian atrium and restored period details.

The Peninsula New York — Fifth Avenue address near MoMA, Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping.

The Peninsula New York — full-service spa, sauna and an indoor pool on property.

The Beekman — multiple in-house venues featuring Tom Colicchio and Daniel Boulud.
The Peninsula New York — Midtown Fifth Avenue location puts MoMA, Rockefeller Center and major shopping within easy reach.
The Beekman — the restored Temple Court Building and Lower Manhattan location are better for visiting Wall Street, the Brooklyn Bridge and the 9/11 Memorial area.
The Peninsula New York has a full-service spa and an indoor pool. The Beekman does not have an on-site spa or pool but arranges in-room spa treatments through the concierge.
Both hotels accept guests of all ages, though both list a minimum age (21) to reserve a room or to be the registered occupant at check-in.
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·