
The Beekman
Best for travelers who value landmark architecture, dining-led stays, and a Lower Manhattan (Financial District) base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Beekman is a five-star boutique-luxury hotel inside the restored 1881 Temple Court Building with a dramatic nine-story atrium and chef-driven restaurants; read this if you want landmark architecture, downtown access, and pronounced culinary programming. The New York EDITION is a five-star Madison Square Park–area lifestyle hotel aimed at design- and nightlife-oriented travelers; read this if you want a stylish, centrally located Midtown-meets-flatiron base with contemporary rooms and nightlife energy.
Updated

Best for travelers who value landmark architecture, dining-led stays, and a Lower Manhattan (Financial District) base.

Best for travelers who want a stylish Madison Square Park lifestyle hotel with easy access to Flatiron and midtown dining and nightlife.
When The Beekman wins: pick The Beekman if you want a distinctive historic setting (the restored Temple Court Building and nine‑story atrium), multiple signature restaurants by high-profile chefs, and a downtown Financial District location near the Brooklyn Bridge and 9/11 Memorial.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you prefer a contemporary, design-forward Midtown/Flatiron location close to Madison Square Park, a smaller modern-room inventory, and a hotel positioned toward nightlife and lifestyle travelers.
Bottom line: both are five-star luxury hotels with style and nightlife-adjacent programming; The Beekman trades modern lifestyle minimalism for landmark architecture and multiple signature restaurants, while The New York EDITION offers a sleeker Madison Square Park–area lifestyle stay. Your choice depends on whether location/heritage (Beekman) or a modern EDITION vibe (New York EDITION) matters more.
| Category | The Beekman | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, landmark boutique with a dramatic atrium and refined, restaurant-forward programming | Stylish luxury-lifestyle hotel focused on modern design and nightlife-adjacent programming |
| Location | 123 Nassau Street — Financial District; near Brooklyn Bridge, One World Trade Center, Battery Park | 5 Madison Avenue — Madison Square Park / Flatiron area; steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building |
| Size (rooms) | 287 rooms (including 38 suites; two turret penthouse duplex suites) | 271 rooms |
| Ages / booking minimum | Adults-leaning; minimum age to reserve a room is 21 | Not published |
| Pools | No on-site pool or hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three venues (Temple Court by Tom Colicchio, The Bar Room, Le Gratin by Daniel Boulud) plus late-night/lounge spaces | One restaurant (The Clocktower) and two bars/lounges; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; concierge-arranged in-room spa services (10% guest discount); 24-hour bi-level fitness center with Peloton bikes | Onsite massages and facials listed; fitness facilities available and spa services on site |
| Known for | Restored Temple Court Building, nine-story Victorian atrium, chef-driven dining and turret penthouses | EDITION brand design and nightlife-lifestyle positioning in the Madison Square Park area |
| Meetings & event spaces | Multiple historic meeting rooms and event venues (Cellar, Kelly Room, Farnsworth, Clinton Hall); rooftop buyout options | Conference space ~2100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Pets | Dogs up to 35 lbs allowed (nonrefundable pet fee; dogs not permitted in The Bar Room/restaurants) | Pets allowed with surcharge (pet fee published in supplier listing) |
The Beekman sits at 123 Nassau Street in Lower Manhattan’s Financial District, close to historic downtown landmarks.
Choose The Beekman for easy access to Lower Manhattan landmarks and ferries to Statue of Liberty/Ellis Island.
The New York EDITION is at 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Pick the EDITION for a central Midtown/Flatiron base with park-side access and easy access to midtown restaurants and nightlife.
The Beekman’s rooms and suites reflect the landmark building’s architecture, including two turret penthouses with private rooftop terraces.
The Beekman emphasizes period character and larger signature suites in a historic setting.
The New York EDITION offers contemporary-design rooms typical of the EDITION brand across a 271-room inventory.
The New York EDITION focuses on modern style, tech-forward rooms, and a range of suite and loft layouts.
Dining is a major draw at The Beekman, with multiple celebrated restaurants and a dedicated bar room.
The Beekman is the stronger pick for guests who want multiple, high-profile in-house dining options.
The New York EDITION lists The Clocktower as its primary on-site restaurant plus two bars/lounges.
The EDITION suits guests seeking a single signature hotel restaurant plus bar-driven nightlife.
The Beekman does not have an on-site pool; its signature public spaces and rooftop penthouses are focal points.
Expect notable public architecture and rooftop terraces rather than a pool at The Beekman.
Pool information for The New York EDITION is not published in the supplier listing.
The EDITION emphasizes in-house treatments, fitness, and nightlife spaces; pool details are not published.
The Beekman pairs in-room spa services with a 24-hour fitness center and late-night bar programming.
Wellness at The Beekman combines in-room treatments and a fully equipped fitness center alongside late-night bars.
The New York EDITION presents spa treatments, fitness facilities, and an EDITION-style nightlife approach.
The EDITION mixes in-house treatments and fitness with brand-led nightlife and bar programming for guests looking for a contemporary social scene.

The Beekman — choose it for the restored 1881 Temple Court Building, nine‑story atrium, and turret penthouse suites.

The New York EDITION — ideal if you want to be steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron/5th Avenue corridor.

The Beekman — home to Temple Court (Tom Colicchio), Le Gratin (Daniel Boulud), and The Bar Room.

The New York EDITION — the EDITION brand offers contemporary design, nightlife-friendly bars, and an urban lifestyle focus.
The Beekman — it's in the Financial District near the Brooklyn Bridge, Battery Park ferry departures, One World Trade Center, and the 9/11 Memorial.
The Beekman — it lists three distinct dining venues (Temple Court, The Bar Room, Le Gratin); The New York EDITION lists one main restaurant and two bars/lounges.
The Beekman does not have an on-site pool; pool information for The New York EDITION is not published in the supplier listing.
Both properties accept pets with fees noted in their policies; The Beekman allows dogs up to 35 lbs with a published pet fee, and The New York EDITION lists a pet fee in its supplier listing.
Explore how The Beekman stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·